|
Indus Valley script
Egyptian script
'European Community' in Chinese characters typed on the computer.
|
The major difference between pictographic and phonetic scripts is that while
in the former the individual symbols represent ideas and objects, in the
latter the symbols stand for sounds.
Thus in Japanese the character for
"horse" ultimately derives from a picture of a horse; the same character,
when read by a Chinese or Korean, still means the same thing but already
pronounced differently. It is sort of like the use of numerals in the West:
1, 2, 3, 4 mean the exact same thing all over Europe but pronounced "one,
two, three, four" in English, "odin, dva, tri, chetyri" in Russian, and "un,
deux, trois, quatre" in French. They represent the concept of the number,
regardless of its sound value.
People have been using various symbols as records for some 30,000 years,
but the first civilization that used true writing was that of the Sumerians,
shortly followed by the Egyptian culture. Beside this, the Chinese, the
Mesoamerican Indians, and the Indus Valley civilization also invented
unique pictographic systems. The Mesoamerican and the Indus Valley scripts
turned out to be a dead end with no heirs. The other three scripts are the
ancestors of all other writing systems in the world, both phonetic and
pictographic.
As far as we know, all phonetic systems at one point evolved out of
pictographic ones. This circumstance had led certain scholars to the belief in
"developed" and "primitive" writing systems; the idea was that those scripts
which were still using pictographic characters were merely at a lower stage of
evolution than those with alphabetic or monosyllabic symbols.
Seemingly, the
two dozen letters of the Roman alphabet seems much easier to both learn and
to use than the 5-6,000 characters of written Chinese language where every
symbol is a unique word and has to be memorized separately. Yet the practice
shows that children in countries using the alphabet do not learn to read and
write faster than those in Japan or China: the road from learning the individual
letters of the alphabet to actually reading and comprehending written text is
a long and laborious process.
Sometimes there are other opinions voiced saying that in the age of
technology and computerization, pictographic languages are becoming obsolete:
the high number of symbols makes the input of these languages tedious and
unnecessarily time-consuming. But in reality, nothing is further from truth
than this. Because each character stands for an entire word and idea,
inputting a single character means the input of an entire word. In English
on the average it takes about four keystrokes followed by a space to input
a word; using the pinyin input system in Chinese it takes about five,
and the space is not required; but while typing phrases and entire sentences
makes no difference in keystroke number, in Chinese it significantly
reduces the number. In English, the phrase 'European Community' consists of 18 keystrokes,
in Chinese it can be entered with 3.
Today's major pictographic systems are the Chinese characters used in
China, Japan, Korea, while all other writings are phonetic, including the
mono-syllabic systems of Katakana and Hiragana in Japan, the Devanagari in
South-East Asia etc, and the different alphabetic scripts all over the
world. Almost all European alphabets are based on the Greek and Roman
alphabet, with certain modification and adaptation.
|